Fannie, Freddie did not cause the housing crisis

Fannie, Freddie did not cause the housing crisis

This is an old theme, but it bears repeating when new information is presented. The right keeps blaring that liberals caused the housing bubble by showering money upon poor people through Fannie Mae and
Freddie Mac. So it must be repeatedly countered. I have no love for Fannie/Fred. Almost nobody other than the Wall Street Journal's editorial page was more critical of them than me in the years leading up to the disaster. They were ghastly government/private mutants, with taxpayers taking on all the risk and shareholders reaping incredible profits until the end.

But the fact is that they played a relatively minor role in the subprime bubble. They got into subprime only after they started losing market share to Wall Street, which was leading the subprime and Alt-A parade. They never had more than 13 percent of their originations in subprime. The table below shows the action. It's from a new "autopsy" of Fannie and Fred, of which the NYT's Economix blog has a good summary.

The vast majority of loan defaults have not been made by the poor. And Fannie & Fred weren't lending much to low-income folks anyway.