In Maryland, the state police have video cams on the dashboard of their cruisers to record their stops. The video and audio recordings are public and they are able to do so because, it is said, when a police officer stops you, the stop is considered to be public with no expectation of privacy.
However, if anyone in Maryland video records a police officer, you can be arrested and charged with a wire tapping crime if you capture the audio.
From the driver's side emerged a man in a gray pullover and jeans. The
man, who was wielding a gun, repeatedly yelled at Graber, ordering him
to get off his bike. Only then did Maryland State Trooper Joseph D.
Uhler identify himself as "state police" and holster his weapon. Graber,
who'd been observed popping a wheelie while speeding, was cited for
doing 80 in a 65 mph zone. Graber accepted his ticket, which he says he
deserved.
A week later, on March 10, Graber posted his video of the encounter on
YouTube. What followed wasn't a furor over the police officer's behavior
but over Graber's use of a camera to capture the entire episode.
On April 8, Graber was awakened by six officers raiding his parents'
home in Abingdon, Md., where he lived with his wife and two young
children. He learned later that prosecutors had obtained a grand jury
indictment alleging he had violated state wiretap laws by recording the
trooper without his consent.
...
"The question is: Is a police officer permitted to have a private
conversation as part of their duty in responding to calls, or is
everything a police officer does subject to being audio recorded?"
Cassilly said.
Cassilly thinks officers should be able to consider their on-duty
conversations to be private. Other officers share that view and have
issued warnings to documentarians. Another
video that surfaced on YouTube shows a Baltimore police officer at
the Preakness warning a cameraman who was recording several other
officers subduing a woman that such recordings are illegal.
...
David Rocah, an attorney for the American Civil Liberties Union of
Maryland who is part of Graber's defense team, said on-duty officers
have no expectation of privacy while doing their job in public. If
police need to talk to an informant, they can have a private
conversation, he said. "But when they are public officials performing
their duty for everyone to see and hear, that is not a private
conversation," Roach said.
The police going to the parent's home and conducting a raid, wasn't about a crime, it was plan Gestapo tactics to intimidate them and send a message to others.
Recent Comments