The phrase for the day is "garbage in, garbage out."
I'm going to break down commentary concerning middle class Blacks
and poor Blacks and the "responsibility" of middle class Blacks.
Actually, I'm going to look at the fallacies involved in the
commentary. Thus, I will show GIGO in action.
This is part of a post at Booker Rising:
The May Essence magazine examines the growing divisiveness between poor blacks and the black middle class today. Of course there is a divide: Those of us who've 'made it' have been taught to despise those who didn't.
There is more to the quote, some of which I believe in, but I really tire of statements based on myths and/or fallacies, being used as a starting point for an article or "conversation" because the myth or fallacy, gains credibility.
For example, here is a link to information concerning Black philanthropy:
Her belief may not surprise other black people who give to churches and charities. According to a national study published this month, black Americans give a higher percentage of their income to charitable causes than any other racial group.
The Chronicle of Philanthropy study is the first to examine how housing, food, taxes and other costs of living affect the percentage of income donated to charity. The study examined giving patterns by people who earn $50,000 or more and itemize deductions on their taxes. The metropolitan area surfaced as
the fifth most generous area in the country.
A separate Chronicle study that looked at giving at all income levels found that black people give 25 percent more of their discretionary income to charity than do others. For instance, black people who make
between $30,000 and $50,000 give an average of $528 annually, compared with $462 donated by their white counterparts in the same income range.
I remember reading an article by Michelle Singletary that pointed out people in the Black middle don't have the same amount of disposable income as whites in their income range because Blacks use a portion of their income to help out less well off family members.
While Sherri Winston makes good points after the quote I provided, I can't get past her initial fallacy.
Booker Rising points to this related post:
No one is their brother's keeper within their own race. In fact that is the sort of talk that held back discussions on what is going wrong for a sizable amount of blacks within the community. The responsibility to the community regardless of race in some respects is for those who have "made it" make the effort to help create/nurture/guard opportunities for others to follow. That means not encourage or demand giving handouts or make excuses for failure.
I really don't know what to say about this one, given I disagree so much with the statement. I'll make a simple statement and leave it at that.
If Blacks have no responsibility to be the brother's keeper of others in our race, why is a lot of the commentary coming from "the right" about Blacks NOT being the brother's keeper? You can't have it both ways. You can't praise Cosby for saying what he said when he IS trying to be the brother's keeper.
There is more for me to write about this, but the truth is, I'm bored going over the same things.
Recent Comments