Here's a money quote, right chayah....
When I get some free time, I'm going to compare Obama's address to GW
Bush's. That should be more fun than a barrel of monkeys. In the
meantime, read all of Obama's "you're on your own" rhetoric like you
should: The well is empty and that fiction y'all call black politics
ain't going to deliver squat.
That's at the core of that rhetorical sewer that I've come down on in a few posts. Instead of being straight up about the core of his thought, he wrote mainly a turd to drill down to this: Black politics, aka identity politics when the phrase is used by conservatives, doesn't work.
If he said the Black community is fractured enough that there is no core set of political goals that can fit under a "Black politics" umbrella, then I could have agreed. I could have pointed out on the AFROAM-L listserv I wrote that it makes little sense for people to expect a Black consensus in politics at this point. For example, my family members who are not doing well, are more worried about the safety of their neighborhoods, job opportunities, and public schools. My family members who are more well off are more worried about 401(K), moving into neighbhorhoods with good school systems, being a part of the schooling of their children, legacy wealth, politics, and other things. There's a disconnect and it's because of money.
Or maybe I would have pointed out my defense of Jack & Jill and how J&J is a part of Black America no matter how much people want to define the Black community as the poor Black America.
Or maybe I would have, again, written on his blog that the Congressional Black Caucus, as a group, is useless because, as a group, they don't know how to use the power they SHOULD have in the Democratic Party.
Or, maybe it, I would have pointed out, again, supporting Jewish causes to get the Jewish vote is identity politics. I would have pointed out that making sure you speak to Christian groups and throwing them "red meat" is identity politics. I also would have pointed out, again, that anti-identity politics IS identity politics. Refusing to address gay Republicans because "the religious Right" would see it as "pandering to gays" is identity politics. I would have pointed out that refusing to ask for the Black vote or address Black groups even when they ask Republicans to address them, is identity politics.
Or, if I was in a snarky mood, I would have pointed out that OUR party, the Republican party, has had some recent identity politics screw ups missteps and he, Cobb, hasn't written jack about it but will complain at times about non-Republican Blacks attacking Black Republicans?
Cobb's piece was pure rhetorical small minded partisan pettiness.
I ain't done...
[ Update ] Project 21 is identity politics.
Recent Comments